top of page

REVIEW: Sherlock Holmes - Woodward Productions, Neil Gooding Productions, QPAC

Nov 15
4 min read

Updated: 17m

Production: Sherlock Holmes – The Mystery of the Valkyrie

Presented by: QPAC, Woodward Productions, and Neil Gooding Productions

Venue: Playhouse, QPAC

Date Attended: 14 November 2026

Writer & Director: Michael Futcher

Producer: Alex Woodward

Set & Costume Designer: Isabel Hudson

Video Designer: Craig Wilkinson

Lighting Designer: David Walters

Composer & Sound Designer: Phil Slade

Choreographer: Dan Venz

Photography: Joel Devereux

 

“Can you ever completely know someone?”

Woodward Productions' Sherlock Holmes – The Mystery of the Valkyrie returns to QPAC following its 2023 premiere, bringing Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's detective into an original mystery written and directed by Brisbane's Michael Futcher. Narrated by Dr John Watson, the story begins with a murder at Birlstone Manor before unravelling into a conspiracy involving a biological weapon, sinister secrets, and the criminal mastermind Professor Moriarty. The word 'Valkyrie' crops up in Norse mythology, Wagnerian opera, and a recurring tattoo - each adding another piece to an already crowded puzzle.


Sherlock Holmes holds the record as the most portrayed human literary character in film and television, so we've had plenty of opportunities to form our own ideas of him. Eugene Gilfedder's Holmes is wearier, sarcastic, and perfectly dry. He has the familiar deerstalker, coat, pipe, violin, and magnifying glass, alongside a sharp tongue and terrible bedside manner. I couldn't help comparing him to Dr Gregory House from House M.D. Both walk with a cane, rely on painkillers, have little patience for stupidity, and approach solving puzzles like a competitive sport. The people suffering at the centre of their investigations are almost an inconvenience to the intellectual challenge.


Gilfedder's brisk delivery and dismissive responses capture that detachment. He delivers sarcastic remarks without the slightest indication he's joking, often working out the significance of a clue before another character has finished explaining it. You can practically hear his impatience with everyone else's slower thought processes.


Ian Stenlake's Watson is highly expressive and perpetually exasperated, spending much of his time trying to keep his brilliant friend under control. Between puns, interjections, and the occasional stolen punchline, Stenlake brings some welcome humour to the proceedings. His narration also guides us through the changing locations and complicated investigation. Poor Watson appears permanently stressed, yet there he is, following Holmes into another dangerous situation.


Helen Cassidy is thoroughly entertaining as the Scottish Inspector Macdonald, whose exchanges with Holmes provide further opportunities for his superiority complex to flourish. Alongside Danny Brown's Sergeant Turner, she contributes to some of the production's playful moments. I also had a soft spot for the elderly servant Ames, who offers some endearing comic relief among the murder and mayhem.


Helen Howard brings a theatrical intensity to Irene Adler, whose threats carry genuine danger. Bryan Probets, meanwhile, has a talent for elaborate villainous monologues as Professor Moriarty, with all the flair of a classic British thriller. Moriarty always appears one step ahead of everyone, including the man who's usually one step ahead of everyone else.


Several actors tackle multiple roles, with Stephen Hirst appearing to take on more than anyone else. He's a brilliantly versatile performer, slipping between characters with ease. However, the doubling can complicate an already demanding plot. I overheard audience members trying to establish which character they were watching, and when a mystery relies on recognising faces, names, and connections, that confusion doesn't help.


Thankfully, there's plenty to look at while your brain catches up! Isabel Hudson's set design is exceptionally inventive. Staircases, doors, and alcoves shift around the stage, transforming into different rooms, buildings, and streets. The scenery rarely sits still, and coordinating the performers, moving pieces, and technical effects must be a logistical nightmare. I'd love to see the backstage cue sheet! A chase through London's alleyways is particularly exciting. Characters dart between doorways and disappear around corners as projected streets extend beyond the physical set. It's almost like a virtual ride, with the audience rushing through the city alongside them. The precision of the movement is impressive, and the sequence is enormous fun.


Craig Wilkinson's video design is superb (as I've come to expect from his work). Backdrops establish locations, while ciphers, calculations, and shifting imagery draw us into Holmes's investigation. The projections interact with Hudson's scenery, extending and transforming the physical spaces. My favourite use of the technology comes when the action rewinds. Earlier events replay in slow motion, revealing details we've missed and filling in the gaps in Holmes's deductions. It plays like a film flashback, letting us watch the detective reconstruct a situation instead of simply explaining it afterwards. For once, we get a glimpse inside that extraordinary mind. I also found it rather satisfying to discover that the tiny detail I'd barely noticed twenty minutes earlier was, of course, important.



David Walters' lighting adds to the shadowy atmosphere, with characters frequently scurrying through dark streets and suspicious corridors. Phil Slade's sound design heightens the tension through gunshots and ominous music, including Wagner's famous Ride of the Valkyries. Michael Futcher maintains a relentless pace throughout. The cast's enunciation is excellent, which is fortunate because there's barely time to process one revelation before another arrives. Names, motives, and clues pile up, demanding your full attention. Holmes may find everything elementary, but I certainly didn't!


I also recognised several plot developments from existing Sherlock Holmes stories. Futcher incorporates familiar characters and elements from Conan Doyle's writing into his mystery, so anyone acquainted with those tales may anticipate certain twists. I suspect audiences less familiar with the source material will encounter a few more surprises.


Even when I'd guessed where a clue was leading, I enjoyed watching the production piece everything together. There's considerable pleasure in seeing such elaborate stage machinery operate with the pace and precision of a film, particularly when the action rewinds to show us what Holmes has already figured out. The game is afoot. Bring your thinking cap!



Comments


IMG_7102.jpeg

Acknowledgement of Traditional Custodians

We pay our respects to the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ancestors of this land, their spirits and their legacy. The foundations laid by these ancestors gives strength, inspiration and courage to current and future generations, both First Nations and non-First Nations peoples, towards creating a better Queensland.

©2024 by Stage Buzz Brisbane

bottom of page